Page #: 689/710 |
@cantona | 5 August 15 | |
I realised Macheda was s**te the first game he started for us. Fergie was quick to get rid of trouble makers but one of his faults was that players stayed at United long after their sell by date as long as they toed the line. Van Gaal has one up on him on that score
|
||
@alanball | 5 August 15 | |
Back to my point the other day, Rooney is a trouble maker and he got to stay and was reward for it. Surprised a Scouse is allowed to rule the roost.
|
||
@bigdunc | 5 August 15 | |
so by Spartans theory every player who Liverpool signed from champions league sides who never made the grade at Liverpool and sold back to champions league sides are in actual fact quality players on the basis of Rafael
|
||
@spartan2 | 6 August 15 | |
@ alanball - 5.08.15 - 11:10am I remember saying in here years ago that Macheda was s**t and living off that Villa game and Spartan told me i was talking s**t Wrong. Your memory is as useful as your points- that was viner Don't make me bump the Carrick/Fellaini argument. It really doesn't look good. It was insane how right I was during that, not least of all because I predicted United could buy him, I predicted he would be proven to come up short against even Carrick, and I also predicted you would end up with another United midfield reject and not complain about it!!!! This was 3 years ago, that is how insanely right I have been! |
||
@spartan2 | 6 August 15 | |
@ alanball - 5.08.15 - 11:09am I work near st helen with quite a few United fans. One is obviously biased as he thinks smalling is world class but none of them come close to agreeing that Rafael is as good as Coleman in over a year none of the United fans on here have agreed with, quite a few have agreed with me on here though When we had this discussion, Rafael had a fantastic season at just 22 and a match for any of Colemans at that position. I'm sure I don't need to clarify that had he stayed fit which was what I said, he would have made it at United. Instead he'll just have to settle for Champions League football elsewhere. |
||
@spartan2 | 6 August 15 | |
@ bigdunc - 5.08.15 - 09:58pm so by Spartans theory every player who Liverpool signed from champions league sides who never made the grade at Liverpool and sold back to champions league sides are in actual fact quality players on the basis of Rafael No, by my theory Rafael won a bunch of stuff at United, had an excellent season when he was just 22 and fit, then struggled badly for injuries, form and then favour after that season. Shown the door and yet it's still a Champions League side come calling to make him their first choice. Not West Brom or Nantes or whoever |
||
@spartan2 | 6 August 15 | |
I don't know how true it actually is but allegedly United demanded more money because of Di Maria's pictures in Qatar when he shouldn't have been there yet
|
||
@viner | 6 August 15 | |
*
@ spartan2 - 6.08.15 - 12:39am Wrong. Your memory is as useful as your points- that was viner Don't make me bump the Carrick/Fellaini argument. It really doesn't look good. It was insane how right I was during that, not least of all because I predicted United could buy him, I predicted he would be proven to come up short against even Carrick, and I also predicted you would end up with another United midfield reject and not complain about it!!!! This was 3 years ago, that is how insanely right I have been! That wasn't me commenting on Macheda. |
||
@alanball | 6 August 15 | |
Stopped reading at 'that was viner'
|
||
@alanball | 6 August 15 | |
It came about because Spartan thought Rooney was worthless in the team and wanted Macheda to replace him in the starting line up
|
||